rdr2 valentine massacre. You can also meet. rdr2 valentine massacre

 
 You can also meetrdr2 valentine massacre  Damn that’s a shame

-I work slowly so that I can get as much detail as possible. [deleted] • 5 yr. 0:00 / 8:01 Red Dead Redemption 2 - Valentine Massacre [PC, 4K] CINEMATIC GAMING 328K subscribers Subscribe 62 3K views 3 years ago Dutch and Arthur meet Leviticus Cornwall. unless somebody runs off to get the sheriff. It is run by Bob Mattice. The region's southern. #3 - Blackwater Returns From Red Dead Redemption In RDR2 Blackwater is a place players can freely access in the Epilogue as John, but if fans decide to visit the area as Arthur, they could quickly get killed due to the bounty on the. An easy way (imo) to raise honor is to greet lots of npc’s. . I made about $3,025. Locations. The town of Valentine has reported many strange sights and sounds in recent years, and residents speak of a curse that has fallen on the area. Mine is doing the same thing. With interest. Hahaxd. Glad devs have learnt. While the small town of Armadillo is the first settlement that players visit in Red Dead Redemption, when John Marston arrives in the town during RDR2. "Items" is more often used in the context of videogames; in real life it's usually products or a more specific term like produce, groceries, clothing etc. You can rob the illegal side business of doctor in Valentine twice. And that you will keep on visiting throughout the adventure. Given its location, and that the words eagle, and owl are both capitalized, and this grave is away from all the other ones around Fort Riggs, it's possible that the ones who laid the Valentine curse were the survivors of the Native American Massacre that took place there, (another thing that was cut you were supposed to originally find out. 256K subscribers in the RDR2 community. This Is A Linear Mission Sequence. As I rode into Valentine, I had no idea that my simple plan to get a haircut would take a turn for the worse. • 9 days ago. This Chance Encounter is only triggered in saloons, where a drunk man challenges Arthur to a duel. . Robbing the bank in Valentine with Karen and Bill. Keep an eye on the front door. 7k more. Occurring in a dense city, this incident is also widely known for the. If the Cores would drain much faster, it would also be a Simulation with Eating, Sleeping etc. Im aware this was a common glitch. She also says it's something about a massacre of Indians, like what happened in Fort Riggs. Killing Everyone in Valentine (Arthur Goes Berserk) - Red Dead Redemption 2ScereBro: • Facebook:. I really want to go back and save the guy but my previous save is a bit further. Clear out the camp & eliminate the hunters. Good night sweet one-legged prince. Hanging Dog Ranch is a potential spawn point for a Gang Hideout. 247K subscribers in the RDR2 community. By 1911, the massacre had gained wide publicity due to the number of men killed. This is also known as the Gunslinger Quest. The Jail was established at some point prior to 1898. . Kentucky Saddler. 442K subscribers in the reddeadredemption2 community. Hanging Dog Ranch. A variation of the event happens in the Rhodes Saloon. We Loved Once and True Part 2. Hosea and Arthur were working on a real estate scam so they weren't involved. 177. 91. The primacy of this place improved the city to look more vibrant, more pleasant. In Red Dead Redemption 2, Valentine will be the first populated town. I read online that you have to threaten the teller, but I aim my weapon at him and the bank guard stops me and I can no longer interact with the teller. The Heartlands is a constituent region of the New Hanover territory in Red Dead Redemption 2. He states that he and his father lived with his mother’s tribe until the US Army. 7k more. Apparently Karen heard the tale from someone in town and naturally Mary-Beth was intensely curious since she seems to be into Gothic horror/romance novels and is even an amateur writer herself. . Most of the rps we do after the blackwater heist are our own version of the story!Finding And Taking Down RDR2's Serial Killer. They get nervous about coming in the front if you toss a few sticks of dynamite their way. 5 mo. • 14 days ago. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. Choice: Crack the safe yourself or blow them open with dynamite. This is a rather interesting mission - Arthur participates in a peaceful. This Challenge is so bugged. Poor chicken, though. Red Dead Redemption 2. r/RDR2. ago. You can also meet. Instead of running away, Micah decides to start a massacre and even kill two residents to retrieve his revolvers. A Headshot Is A Headshot. The Valentine Church. The Pagan Skull Mask can be found at a ritual site by heading to the game's barriers. Galloping through the RDR2 frontier since 2018. The first murder scene is just outside of Valentine. seashore_massacre. Considering it happened in 1899, I get the feeling R* wanted to make RDR2 and include this massacre in it, whilst making RDR1. If I have to pick one then Valentine wins for the Chapter 2 memories and the majestic mountain backdrop. Please help I can buy guns or any ammo now. We added benches, light poles on the streets, more objets in front of the shops. • 2 yr. Valentine is a settlement in Red Dead Redemption 2 and Red Dead Online in The Heartlands region of the New Hanover territory. please take a second to give a channel like and subscribe for more videos:. but yeah ive beat plenty of people senseless in valentine. Valentine’s Day Massacre shocked the world on February 14, 1929, when Chicago’s North Side erupted in gang violence. According to Sheriff Malloy, the unnamed prostitute murdered several men before encountering the player. FPS drop in certain part of Valentine only. After freeing the animal, mount your horse again and follow Miller until you reach the hunters' camp. Become my patron:are the Slaughter Mask, Creature Mask, Horror Mask, Swing Mask, Freak Mask, and Masquerade Mask. From what I’ve seen (and I could be wrong) the story ends when you go to blackwater with Horley and [I can’t spell her name and I’m not going to try] I think the only story missions after that are for the moonshiner role. Mod Organizer 2 - RDR2 Plugin (Profile-specific Saves) 14:54. Or, treasure hunting. Reddit community for discussing and sharing content relating to Red Dead Redemption… Murder 1: South of Valentine. The worst part is riding through and your horse slowing down to slower than walking speed. Boards. things get wild today. my guess would be that you're missing one of those. John Marston is a recurring character in the Red Dead series, appearing as a central character and the primary protagonist of Red Dead Redemption, and as a central character and the secondary protagonist of Red Dead Redemption 2. Going to an affluent place like parts of Saint Denis will provide you with many people with large hats to shoot off - but you'll have to face the consequences for your hat massacre. Go upstairs in the building next to the bar and you can use the hallway leading to the outside stairs as a fatal funnel. Fall of the West - RDR2 RP. Gallery. You'll also get an Offer for a 50% discount on any Established or Distinguished Role Item whenever you emote to another player within 72 hours of doing it. Also you can see a cliff off to the right in the sketch, which the peninsular camp contains many of. 240. Basically everywhere in the game even Saint Denis I get 50-65 FPS however I came back on the game today for the first time in a while and went into Valentine and at. from the way they. In the saloon, while I was a drinking a beer, the waiter told me that the sheriff in town found a women who kills several mans by pretending to be a whore. 90. Disarming the opponent leads to an increase in Honor by 2 points. Please tell me what. In RDR2, clearly Arthur is the better shot But, in RDR (which is John’s prime era) John is a waaaay better shot imo. You can also google "Strange Statues Quest" to find a walkthrough and puzzle solution. Head around back to see the business. You can play as an honorable outlaw, helping out people in need and being a good person. So I'm trying to beat the game 100% and when passing by Valentine I saw in my minimap two corpse markers (X) in a locked house. So earlier on today I was casually strolling through Valentine, on my way to the butcher's, when suddenly I was downed by a headshot out of nowhere. Outlaws from the West is the first storyline mission in Red Dead Redemption 2. This is a red dead redempti. Targeting Leviticus Cornwall and his business over and over again prompted the man to act, leading to a massacre in Valentine and the gang being forced to leave the Horseshoe Outlook camp. Your goal is to climb it and find the hidden. (I also recommend bringing a pump action shotgun but it's fine without it) After you've discovered the robery, go around the back where the locked metal door is. hailtoantisociety128 • 2 yr. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites. 362 votes, 28 comments. . gives you a new appreciation for arthurs character and how he justifies his actions in the cutscenes. Red Dead Redemption II is a western action-adventure video game created by Rockstar, serving as a prequel to Red Dead Redemption and an interquel to Red Dead Revolver. Just arrived at Horseshoe Overlook for the 4th time where I will be spending the next 6 months of my real life with the gang. 3. Much like the first mysterious shack, RDR2’s first serial killer victim is quite close to one of the starting areas, designed to pique your interest so you keep an Eagle Eye out for more… As Gory As RDR2 Gets. 7. . But you actually have to look through the window or wait until you see someone go in or out the back door. r/reddeadredemption. The Serial Killer. With the heat in Valentine having died down, Bill decides it's finally time to hit the bank. In my case I've had to undervolt my gpu to make crashes less frequent, even though every other game works fine. Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted. Iynxell • 3 yr. Support me on Patreon: Four Pillars Network:Not sure if it's a glitch in my game but so far, I've shot the hell out of that town ten or fifteen times without getting a bounty. Or maybe my horse enjoyed it an lied to me, either way, bonding. There’s a set of low honor story missions and high honor ones. A hidden photo leads us to a mysterious graveyard in Valentine. There were also four Native American artifacts buried in different spots near the town, with a mask that spawns on the counter at the local gunsmith. There’s a woman who’s husband was kidnapped, you can go rescue him, you can hunt the legendary animals in New Austin, you can bounty hunt the Del Lobos and Laramine Gang if Arthur didn’t kill him you can hunt Anthony Foreman and you can meet Pearson, Mary-Beth and Tilly in Rhodes, Valentine and Saint Denis respectively. New files. RDR2. It’s actually a really interesting story, the twin brother, George, managed to pin his own crimes on Oscar which leads to him being wrongly arrested. He is the subject of the Stranger mission "American Dreams". r/reddeadredemption. Perhaps the most scandalous shootout in the world of Red Dead Redemption, the Blackwater Heist is a complete misfire and became one of the gang's biggest tragedies. . Source: my horse. In the town Valentine, you can. That’s been my experience at least. Having replayed RDR1 recently it's shocking just how different John is in both games. I read that the O’Driscolls aren’t active past chapter 6, and that appears to be correct as I’ve been all. like in the alleyway between the saloon and store in valentine. comHi there! New to my channel? If. So the public hanging in Valentine where the man shows no regret about what he did and the wife and son are crying in the crowd, the wife hysterically and the boy runs off. Just bought everything from the ledger. Also a bar patron in the saloon outright says there's some lady going around pretending to be a prostitute to kill unsuspecting men. 75. . Go to the window out back look inside, then it will give you the option to rob back room while aiming at the owner. I have dyslexia so to practice my writing I started a video game dairy. Some establishments, the game teaches. In 1898, the Red Dead Online protagonist can accept bounty posters off the board next to the office if they have unlocked the Bounty. Red Dead Redemption 2's gameplay begins in 1889, shortly after the Blackwater Massacre has already taken place. If you spare his life, Arthur tells him that he was indeed in Blackwater and that he killed people. What you seem to be struggling with is the complexity and difficulty of the Wanted/Bounty Systems. Red Dead Redemption 2 - Valetine Doctor's Side Business Robbery With Low Bounty!How to get into the bolted door and rob the side business. What is your best town (or worst) and why. Dutch, Arthur, and Micah head out to look for supplies. Saint Dennis is the one where people intentionally throw themselves in front of your horse and the sheriffs come in shooting. I play the game slowly to enjoy everything, so please tell me what I should do in those right times. Micah's and Dutch's ferry robbery plan is flawed because Hosea wasn't involved. ago. Just a word of advice, Buell is the Best horse in the game stats wise. Stpetter13 • 4 yr. I started a new game and reached Horseshoe Overlook and there was a conversation btwn Karen and Mary-Beth about an alleged curse on the town of Valentine. Arthur is. 0 (Killing Spree)#RDR2 #RedDeadRedemption2 #RedDeadRedemptionThis page takes you through the Stranger Mission or side quest The Noblest of Men, and a Woman in Red Dead Redemption 2. Belgian Draft. Any mod that makes people of valentine forget the massacre I've commited? I just wanna be respected in valentine even tho I have killed thousands of people comment. Serious train massacre in Valentine #reddeadredemtion2 #rdr2 #rdr2shorts #youtubeshorts #shortsYou can download the mod from:list of mods I did for games such as: The Witch. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. Make sure you are not wearing a mask. Read to learn about current events. It seems I've exhausted all other random events in Valentine. 3. white areas mean you can’t equip any weapons or exhibit hostile behaviour, the game will tell you you’re not allowed to use weapons in these places. There is that duel in Valentine, another random duel event just like that one that can take place in front of the saloon in Van Horn, and also a duel event that can happen when you walk into the saloon in Rhodes. Simply log into Red Dead Online on Valentine's Day to receive the following rewards: 5 x Chocolate Bars. A variation of the event happens in the Rhodes Saloon. I do have to add; the game gets a liiiiittle lonely after Arthur dies. Helped her the first time, turned her in the second. I chose to kill him. 159. UMA NOVA HISTÓRIA - Vamos criar uma história diferente mudando o rumo de alguns personagens e alguns desfechos usando MOD. . Micah gets in Dutch's ear about a ferry carrying lots of money. Considering it happened in 1899, I get the feeling R* wanted to make RDR2 and include this massacre in it, whilst making RDR1. Arthur is definitely the best brawler (hand to hand) we see though and he seems smarter than John, at least in RDR2. Enter the front door. Once you've reached the camp, Miller will aggravate them & beat him up. The music feels so eerily haunting, like some unknown horrific evil has been awakened. you can also try the mine at gaptooth ridge to make sure you have the lobos covered. Two versions of. The Saint Valentine's Day Massacre was the murder of seven members and associates of Chicago's North Side Gang that occurred on Saint Valentine's Day 1929. Both of his parents were former slaves. This newspaper is used to display the player's statistics after completing a chapter. Grizzlies. Core Stamina Drain: -4% Core HP Drain: -10% Stamina Regen: 8% Cost: $48 Losing a horse is always a horrible prospect in Red Dead Redemption 2. At the end, if Arthur has bad honor, jack, John and Abigail go to his tomb. THAT is a broken system. 4 Arthur's Hat Found In General Store. Quem sabe um final mais feliz para. The first of these clues is on the ride from Horseshoe Overlook to Valentine. For the first time in all of my hours playing, I witnessed a random encounter I had never seen before. So I’m coming up on 99. Same here, entering Valentine crash My Game . Swadlass Point (West Elizabeth, Aurora Basin) Colter (north amberino) Lake Don Julio House (New Austin, Lake Don Julio) Additional: -Stilt Shack (West Elizabeth, West of Hanging Dog Ranch) -Guthrie Farm (New Hanover, West of Emerald Ranch) -Unknown Shack between Strawberry and Owanjila (West Elizabeth) -Old Bacchus Place (New. One thing I’ve learned as I’ve progressed through Red Dead 2 is that like most Rockstar games, it is very, very much not an RPG. First things first, though, you'll need to visit the first map location. 48. A serious train massacre occurs in Valentine - rdr2#rdr2 #reddeadredemtion2 #reddeadredemption #arthurmorganIn this Red Dead Redemption Arthur gets angry and starts a Brutal Massacre in Valentine. ago. The Truth Behind RDR2’s Blackwater Massacre. Only recently elected, he can usually be found hanging outside Strawberry’s welcome center. 1. I've been trying to check Valentine mostly every night, the three locations where the initial Hotel Robbery (I think its actual official name is 'Town Robbery' though) event can spawn. Go to RDR2 r/RDR2. The Strawberry Jail is a location featured in Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Redemption 2. By entering Keane's Saloon, he meets biographer Theodore Levin, who is attempting to have a. That's the plan, can't let them kill the best waifu of the game. The Blackwater Massacre was an infamous and violent gunfight involving the Van der Linde gang, the Blackwater Police Department, the Pinkerton National Detective Agency and supposedly the famous gunslinger Landon Ricketts, which took place in the town of Blackwater in May 1899 during a robbery on a nearby ferry. 9. As such, it is handy to acquire it as soon as. I just came back to red dead for the new update, and I want to finish my 100% completion eventually. Map description Saint Denis, the "Jewel of Lemoyne," is a. 347. Many structures appear to have been abandoned, one seeming to have burned down, and the. Strawberry is a settlement in Red Dead Redemption 2 and Red Dead Online in the Big Valley region of the State of West Elizabeth. (Grapple Sequences, subdue animations, 5 brawling styles, struggle challenge, charge with knife, shove, kick animations, environmental finishers, new brawl animations and grapple position switching for back and front grapple for every. Not only was I able open every safe and loot. RDR2 True Color and Detail Reshade PRESET. Ever have a friendly boxing match and there's always that one person that just decides to ignore the rules? Here's one of those people and well let's just se. . To find the revolver location, you must combine the two maps. ymap Clean. This Challenge is so bugged. Outlaws from the West is the first storyline mission in Red Dead Redemption 2. At the end, if Arthur has bad honor, jack, John and Abigail go to his tomb. It is assumed that the story of Red Dead Redemption 2 starts at Blackwater in the events of Blackwater Massacre where the Van Der Linde. Go to a crowded part of saint denis and greet everyone. 4 - (14,502 x 10,884) - entire map RDR2 Map - Respawn Loot Locations - Thru Ch. Things to do right after you reach Horseshoe Overlook. 75. user110110110936 • 2 yr. The name can be seen as ironic, due to the abnormal number of unpleasant events that took place there. I like to get in too if the buildings and angle a dynamite arrow down into the saloon to start shit, then snipe the law as they roll in. Tarot card stuck inside locked room in valentine hotel, room 1a . I got him back for it though. Not Valentine, not Saint Denis, none of these places plummet my framerate. Same here. • 5 yr. There's a back story that leads you to a currently inaccessible location near Valentine that will become unlocked. Informing Arthur that him and Karen have planned to rob the bank in Valentine, Bill tells Arthur to come along. 6 min read. The store was founded prior to 1898. OP says he shot up the saloon in chapter 3 or 4 and it’s still closed in chapter 6 which to me just sounds like a bug. Red Dead Redemption: Undead Nightmare is a standalone expansion pack to the 2010 video game Red Dead Redemption. Red Dead Redem. It serves as the capital of the Big Valley region. Chapters00:00 Introduction00:57 Valentine Massacre Scenarios05:42 Beta Bounty Scenarios08:44 B. 5 years old now and is on an older architecture so it gets worse performance in RDR2 than the 20 series cards. I have dyslexia so to practice my writing I started a video game dairy. RDR2 will do you a favor and highlight the area in a Stranger. Stayed that. "The Sheep and The. Go knock on the door at the house that’s. . Doesn't take very long at all to get them all slaughtered. This mission will give you the knowledge you need to purchase goods. Valentine Murder Scene. This way the outcome of the games comes down to just the cards instead of bluffing. NO SPOILERS PLEASE. Much-Bathroom-3461 • 8 mo. xml file in your Documents -> Rockstar Games -> RDR2 ->. It was night in Roanoke Ridge and two guys were driving a wagon. 12:49. As the game begins in the snowy mountains of Colter, the gang is hiding out in the wake of the events of the Blackwater Massacre, with Dutch van der Linde and his right hand, Hosea Matthews, trying desperately to keep their gang. 4K resolution, 60 fps, high graphics settings. Forums. Max Bounty of $1,500 cap. version. It happens after one of the missions in Valentine for some reason, immediately after the mission and even though you have no contact with the guy. You should buy all the outfits first from all the shops because they will give you single items, and if you go to the pause menu under social club go into that should be a prompt at the bottom of screen to view in social club then top screen menu go to games go to rdr2 go on the side menu and go to catalog, you can purchase every outfit including the ones in the. No NPC watches it. I couldn't even go to the metal door and knock or go back to the window and look through it. It adds a non-canonical zombie horror-themed single-player campaign, two multiplayer modes, and cosmetic additions to the environments and characters of the open world Western action-adventure game. . Oh yeah, that's true! You can actually talk to people, go inside random houses and there's a ton of stranger/side missions. Red Dead Redemption 2 is a 2018 action-adventure game developed and published by Rockstar…A serious train massacre occurs in Valentine that they will probably never come back from. then while your riding to the bank you can talk to karen. 6. One of the countless gameplay systems in RDR2 is the Red Dead Redemption 2 Honor level. 130. 0:00 / 8:01 Red Dead Redemption 2 - Valentine Massacre [PC, 4K] CINEMATIC GAMING 328K subscribers Subscribe 62 3K views 3 years ago Dutch and Arthur meet. This easter egg can be found by triggering the stranger mission "American Dreams" in which Arthur is tasked to find a serial killer who dismember body parts of his victims. It has everything you need: coach, train, store, hotel, two saloons, doctor, gunsmith, stable, and barber. The theories for the reasons behind this include the lack of a railway in the. The Red. The Miner's Hat is the only hat in the game that's actually useful instead of decorative. ago. I wanna post an event that happened to me in Valentine. Alternatively, going even farther back would be awesome. Yes the regular vid uploads are backTIL the founder of Blackwater married a 12 year old native American girl after killing her entire family, was best friends with an opossum which he eventually wore as a hat till his dying day, and was inspired to be a congressman after a drug and prostitute fueled binge in Saint Denis. white areas mean you can’t equip any weapons or exhibit hostile behaviour, the game will tell you you’re not allowed to use weapons in these places. This is one of the most pivotal cutscenes in the game, too. 9. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. Low honor arthur got no chillwent into the town of valentine & had some fun. Once I completed this relatively simple heist I walked out with 2. 67. THAT is a broken system. The game is the third entry in t. CryptoInterestingly, running the ingame benchmark does work without crashing multiple times in a row and I could play the whole game till I reached Valentine without a. Bullet For My Valentine - Shatter: 7505702626. Even if they do get the sheriff, the sheriff just comes in, politely waits until you beat said victim unconscious. And this game doesn't stop to surprise me As I was about to go shopping in Valentine Leviticus shows up and well some bulle. Red Dead Online is a multiplayer-focused action-adventure video-game developed by Rockstar San Diego and published by Rockstar Games originally released with Red Dead Redemption 2 and later released as a standalone game on December 1st 2020. It has been confirmed through campfire. in the RDR2 main directory, search for the "stream" folder. When I was taking my sweet time looting. Valentine. Join. What you seem to be struggling with is the complexity and difficulty of the Wanted/Bounty Systems. You. Unhashed some files and made some interesting beta discoveries. When I was taking my sweet time looting. Perfect carcasses go for $5. Première ville rencontrée dans le scénario de Red Dead Redemption 2, Valentine est située à l'ouest de l'État de New Hanover, qui abrite également les villes de Van Horn et. nix1ef41ry • 6 mo. No story spoilers. All of the goods showcased in this. nop, just robbed 4 stores, didn't kill/assault anyone, 1 of them counted. ago. The store offers the same services as in Red Dead Online to Arthur in 1899 and John in 1907. I always just assumed he was simply. The Noblest of Men, and a Woman is a four-part Stranger side-mission in Red Dead Redemption 2. Soldiers from Fort Wallace coming to the town to establish a supply line managed to restore order and now many of the town residents have taken up arms in a defense militia in areas in and just outside town. Gallery. This is especially true for those of you who have developed a bond with your horse, only to find yourself stuck between a rock and a hard place when you take an errant turn without any Horse. Jack Hall Gang Map 1 map, location and treasure. rshep8442 • 1 yr. 10. Buy one from the Valentine Stables in Chapter 2 for $15. Jenny Kirk joined the Van der Linde gang at some point prior to 1899 when they found her abandoned on the side of the road. The West Elizabeth-based town serves as a critical story location in the first game and reprises that role in the prequel. mcsurfyfly • Additional comment actions. I also received an honor boost. Use Dead Eye and a powerful gun to down the boar, then go back to Hamish, who, with his dying words, gives you his horse. Van Horn Trading Post is a settlement featured in Red Dead Redemption 2 and Red Dead Online. . Business, Economics, and Finance. Money collected: $885Rotate the left stick slowly, and if you over click it, rotate back quickly to where you were before. Red Dead Redemption 2 - Valentine hotel robbery (Random Encounter #5)Check my RDR2 random encounters playlist: the area for awhile. Is there a way to replay the valentine robbery doctor robbery mission? I loaded into a save right after I started the mission, killed the O'Driscoll's and when the latest save had loaded, I couldn't trigger the mission anymore. The player could find four parts of a Native American painting of the massacre done on four pieces of hide buried in the overworld near Valentine. Select option to rob back room. About this mod. Polite Society, Valentine Style is a Main Story Mission, and part of IGN’s. Obviously, I also tried during the day, but not as much as I've ran around during nights. Valentine is a nice town. And you should be able to sell to him.